Comments about the tasting of wine

Garretson 2004 Mon Amie Syrah, San Luis Obispo County

Just as I was losing faith in screw caps, along comes a wine that makes me hesitate on totally giving up on them…

Actually a blend of 96% Syrah and 4% Viognier, this selection boasts 14.5% alchohol and is a limited production of only 250 cases. Named for and dedicated to the winemaker’s wife, this wine also boasts a 94 rating from Robert Parker.

The color is a deep, dark, inky blue-black. The nose is rich with dark fruits, cassis, graphite, smoke, and a hint of pepper. Those dark fruits (blackberry, plum, currant), smoke, and yes the pepper too, continue thru the palate with a hint of leather. The finish is long; the smoke and leather diminishing as the pepper takes over.

Do I have any regrets at all?  Yep, it could have cellared another couple years.  To be honest, I just didn’t trust the screw cap… been burned too many times. This is a winner.

September 13th, 2007 Posted by | Wine | 2 comments


  1. That can be the case huh, “damn that’s good, but *damn* that could have been even better after another few years”. :)


    Comment by Edward Yardley | September 17, 2007

  2. This wine really opens up after a few hours of decanting. I’ll follow your advice and keep the rest of my bottles in the cellar for a couple of years. Ready to drink now, I can’t wait to try this wine again after a little aging!

    Comment by Agent Red | September 28, 2007

Leave a comment